sd.gif (2133 bytes)
Robert Todd Carroll

 logo.gif (4146 bytes)
SkepDic.com

vertline.gif (1078 bytes)  

aromatherapy,

1920 ȭ Rene Maurice Gattefosse ܾ, Ĺ̳, , Ѹ, ѵκ ⸧ ̿Ͽ ġϴ ̴. ܾ ټ ǰ ִµ, õ̳ ΰ̳, ⸧ (,ۻ) ü Ϲ ġ ȿ ̴. (ۻ ) ⸧ ˾Ƴų, ٸ ȥյǾ ˾Ƴų, , ġ ȿ ƴϴ. ġȿ ⸧ --װ ⸧ ȭ Ư--̴. , ֹ Ǵ 찡 ִµ 쿡 ׷ ƴϴ. κ 쿡 ⸧ Ǻο ٸų ٸ ῡ ȥϿ ð ȴ. 긦 ̿ؼ 丮 ϴ ̶ ϱ⵵ Ѵ.

(essential oil) ġ̾ , α ̴. ̰ ȸǷ ṉ̀⵵ ϴ. ġ پ ⸧ ȿ ޹ħϴ ٰŴ ° . ⸧ ġ ȿ ϴ κ ͵ Ʒ ȭ κ̴.

    , []ε , Լհ ô ϴ. 2 , ̲ 鼭 ð ø Դϴ. հ ̹ ־ϴ. , ⸧ ʰ հ ߶ϴ. 氥ο ƿ, ɾҰ, ô ͵ ߾ϴ. (ٴϿ ̸, )

̷ post hoc reasoning , ü 忡 dzϴ. (control studies) ϸ ٰŰ ׵ ׷ ʴ´.

    ̻а 丶 ̸ [¼ ¼ ] ǥ߽ϴ. ⼭ ߿ Ÿ ׸Ƹ ̸ ̵ ߿ staphylococci streptococci Եȴٴ ߽ϴ. *

ٸ ġ 츦 ο κ Ʒ ̴.

    Ÿ 𸮴 Ұ ̸ óߴ. ̿ ȿ ִ. , ׳ ᰡ ϰ ȿ ִٰ ϰ ִ. (ٴϿ ̸, , p. 205)

̷ (testimonials) ǽ Ӹ ƴ϶  ŷ ̷ ϴ ɵ . ׵ ̷ ġ žӰ ó ׳ ޾Ƶδ.

ϸ, ġ , ٸ ġ Ĺ̳ ῡ ؼ ϰ ϴ ͵鿡 ̴. ġḦ ϴ ̳ ǰ ü ̸ Ÿ ʴ´. ̵ κ , ϰ ͵̴. ϱ⵵ Ѵ. ,  ⸧ ׵ ̹ ü ļ íũ ߰ ϰ, 帧 ȭӰ ϸ, ´ٰ Ѵ. ̷ ٺ Ұϴ. ̰ ź Ϻκ̰, ġ dz .

ؼ Ǹ Ѵٸ װ,õ ⸧ ռ ⸧ Ѱ ƴѰ ϴ ̸ п οϴ ƹ ҿ ȴ. õ ȣϰ ִ ġ ٴϿ ̸ , "󺥴" ̴. ׳ " (Aromatherapy)", 󺥴 Ĺ, ϰ ִ. ű⿡, 󺥴 , , ȯ ġ̶ 16 Ĺ Mattiole Եǰ ִ. ׳ 󺥴 ּ borneol, geraniol, linalool ̳, geranyle linalyl ȭչ, ׸ pinene limonene ϰ ִ. 󺥴, ׻  󵵷 Եǰ ִ. ׳ , κ , 󺥴 ߿ ϴٰ ִ. ׸ 󺥴 "Ǻ ȭ ġῡ 谡 ִ" ̶ , 󺥴 "汤, , ġῡ ſ ȿ ִ" ִ. μ 󺥴 "ȸ ȯ ħ , Ƽȯ ȭ , ⳪ ÷翣 Ÿ   ø " ϰ ִ. Ʒ ؼ,̸ " 3 ⸧ 2﾿ 󺥴 ⸧ 1½ ⸧ ȥϿ ٸ ϶" ǰϰ ִ. (p. 143) ̷ 󺥴 ޹ħ ߴ ؼ ׳ Ѹ ʾҴ. ׷ ⿡ "ſ ȿ ִ(very effective)" 簡, " (is good)" ǥ Ȯ ƴ, " ȴ"(׳ 󺥴 ϸ Ʈ( : Ǻΰ Ư ̶ Ѵ.) ϴµ ȴٰ ִ.) ָ ƴϴ. ׸, ȭ " 谡 ִ" ̰ ȭ ؼ  ȿ ִٰ ƴϴ. , ̷ ְ Ȯϰ ִٰ Ѵ. , ̸ ġ ̷ ̸ ǽɽ.

, ̸ 󺥴 ׸ 󺥴 Ʈ 氨 ȿ ؼ ̾߱ϰ ʴ. ׷, "Ҹ" ׸ ׳ "󺥴 ۿ ְ, Ű ü Ǯ ϴ Ѵ" ִ. ̰Ϳ ؼ , ̸ ʾҴ. 󺥴 ̿ , , ޽ ڸ ̴. ߿ ޽ ٰ ִ(Dunn).

׷, ϰ źϴ ƴϴ. ⿡ ɸ ڰ , Vicks VapoRub Ѵ. ̰ camphor Į ȥչ̴. ؼ ġḦ ϰ ִٰ ִ. ׷ ó ġ Ī , ̺ ü ̶ . , ΰ , , ȭ, , ɷ , ׸ ̾߱⸦ ׹ ̴. ῩǾ ִ , ͼ ϴ ̴.

See related entry on alternative health practices and Bach's flower therapy.


б ڷ

reader comments

Dunn, C. et al. "Sensing an improvement: an experimental study to evaluate the use of aromatherapy, massage and periods of rest in an intensive care unit," Journal of Advanced Nursing, 21, 1995, pp 34-40.

McCutcheon, Lynn. "What's That I Smell? The Claims of Aromatherapy," Skeptical Inquirer, May/June 1996.

Raso, Jack. "Alternative" Healthcare: A Comprehensive Guide (Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books, 1994).

Copyright 1998
Robert Todd Carroll

larrow.gif (1051 bytes) argument from ignorance

Last updated 10/30/98

astral body rarrow.gif (1048 bytes)