sd.gif (2133 bytes)
Robert Todd Carroll

 logo.gif (4146 bytes)
SkepDic.com

vertline.gif (1078 bytes)  

slick 50 and other engine oil additives

50 ٸ ÷

Slick 50 ̳ Ÿ  ÷ ȿ شٰ Ѵ.

츮 Ʒ ̴.

ǿ , ڵ ϰ Ѵٸ Slick 50 ķ κп ٿشٴ ش. 50 ó ڵ Ȱ 캸 50% پش.

ϴ ٸ ǰ 50 ̹ ڿ ̵ κ ȸ翡 ٸ ̸ ǰ̴. 0.5L Ȥ 1L ÷ ޷ 20޷ ̸ Ѵ. ̷ ǰ ? ణ . ƹ ذ °? ذ ִ.

¶ų, Ȱ ִ°? ׸ װ͵ ׷ Ǹϴٸ, ڵ ü ̰ ϵ ʴ°? ׸ ȸ翡 ÷ پ ʴ°? Petrolon (Slick 50) ޵ ̷ ü ִ°? Ƹ, ȸ ǰ ٴ ִ ijݿ ̴.

̵ ÷ ⺻ ϴ. Slick 50, Liquid Ring, Microlon, Matrix, QM1 ׸ K-Mart T-Plus ٷ Polytetrafluoroethylene̴. ̰ Ϸ PTFE θ ȴ. ̰ ׷ ̰ ̶ θ .  ֳϸ ߸ ÷̳ Ϸδ ٰ ߱ ̴. ׷ ׵  ̰ ˾Ҵ°? ׵ Petrolon(Slick 50) ؼ ߴ.

PTFE ü̸ Ͽ ÷Ǹ ̴ κ Ѵٰ Ѵ.

׷, ̷ ü ʴ κе 帣 ̳ ͸ ϴ ִ. ᱹ з° Ǹ ġ Ǹ, ׷ Ǹ

However, such solids seem even more inclined to coat non-moving parts, like oil passages and filters. After all, if it can build up under the pressures and friction exerted on a cylinder wall, then it stands to reason it should build up even better in places with low pressures and virtually no friction.

̷ NASA ̽ Ϳ PTFE ÷ ׽Ʈ ؼ ȴ. ׵ "츮 ̷  ǥ ˿ 츮  ʾҴ. ʿ ȿ Ÿ. Ͽ Ե ü Աü ̰ ǰ ̰ ġ ֹ ϰ Ǿ  ´. Ǵ ƴ϶ Ȱ ̴.
(Rau).

50 ϱ ؼ University of Utah Engineering Experiment Station Chevy 6 cylinder engine ̿ؼ ǽ 迡 PTFE ÷ 13.1 ۼƮ پ 5.3 8.1 ۼƮ , Ǿ. , 迡 " ͸ ̷ ΰ з ϰ , ̰ Ƹ ε ." м ö ̰ óϱ 2 Ǿµ, ̰ Ѵٴ Ÿ ̴(Rau).

the FTC and Slick 50

1997, Quaker State Corp. 3 ȸ ȸ( Federal Trade Commission) Quaker State's Slick 50 Engine Treatment ̸ ٰŰ ο ݹ ذߴ. FTC ù ϸ, 50 ʴ´ٸ, ڵ Ϲ õ ȣ ϸ, Ͽ premature failure ִٴ ߸ ̴.

" ݵ õ 50 ٸ ݼ ݾ ȴ."

"ѹ ȭ÷׿ ʴ ջ ϴ ̴. ֳϸ ݵ õ κ ִ Ʒʿ ִ. ׷ 50 Ư ȭ Ѵ. ̰ 5 ųιͿ ؼ 50% ҽŲ. "

" 50 ڵü ķ Ưϰ ϴ ȭչ Ű, ̰ սŰ Ưϰ Ȱȭ PTFE Ǿ. "

ǻ, FTC Ѵ. "κ ڵ ϴ Ͽ õ Ϳ ؼ ϰ ȣǰ ִ. Ӹ ƴ϶, Ͽ premature failure Ͼ Ǵ 50 ϰų ʰų ſ ƴϴ.

zinc:

ٸ ÷ zinc dialkyldithiophosphate̴. Zinc-d ߿ Mechanics Brand Engine Tune Up, K Mart Super Oil Treatment, STP Engine Treatment With XEP2 ߰ ȴ.

zinc-d ÷ Ư "Platformate" ִ. (κ ֹ ٸ ̸ ÷ ְ ִ.)

Zinc-d δ ƴ϶ ص κ ֿ ȸ ǰ ԵǾ ִ. Ȱ 50 ȸ Ͽ ÷ ణ ̴.

̰ ݼӰ ݼ ϴ ſ ¶ ̴. "ƿ ȭչ ݼӰ ؼ Ư, Ǹ ǽ   scuffing ָ ... 󱸳 ī (: ̱ ̸Ͼƿ ִ Ʈ ) ð ƴ϶, Ͽ ƿȭչ ߰ϴ Ϲ ׳ ϴ ̴. .., ƿ Է 꿡 Ⱑ ̰ ǰ ȭ ÷װ ۵ ʴ´."(Rau).

zinc-d ٸ, ü ϰ ÷ ǥ ȥչ ణ ÷ ʴ°? δ ȸ zinc-d Է ̰ ִ. װ ϸ ̰ catalytic converters ȿ װ ϱ ̴.

Ѵٸ, ູϰ ȭ ε ϸ ȿ ִٰ ִ ϸ, ÷ ϴ ϴ ڷ ʴ. , 鸸 ̰ Ѵ. װ͵ ٷ ̰ ȿ ִٴ Ű ƴѰ? δ ƴϴ. װ͵ ȸ ִٴ ̴. 

Ϻ ÷ ذ ʰ ٰ Ͽ κ ̰͵ ϵ Ѵ. ϰ ִ ֿ Ǹȸ翡 ̶, ̹ ÷ Ű ԵǾ ֱ ̴. Ű Ư ÷ ȭչ ̷ ̸ µ Ư ߾ ̴. Ϲ, ּ ̵  ȣ ۿ Ѵ. , ׵ Ȥ ̻ ȣ۾ ؼ ׵ δ ȿ . ٲٴ ߰Ѵٴ ó Ű ʿ Ե ߰Ѵٰ ϴ, ̵ ̰ ߴ ȣ ȿ ִ. (Rau).

ü(engine block) ٸ ̵ ÷ ϰ ľ ʴ ÷̴. Bardahl, Rislone ׸ Marvel Mystery Oil ̰͵ ϰ ε巴 شٰ Ѵ. ׵ Ÿ ٿشٴ ̴. ̷ ǰ ɷν(kerosine), Ż, Ϸ(xylene), Ƽ Ȥ ̼ (isopropanol) ų Ȱ ִ. θ Ѵٸ ⿣ ǰ ̳ ƿ ȣ ܳ ̴! ׷ ǰ ٷ ƴ϶ Ȥ ׿ִ ʿ䰡 ̴. ׷Ƿ ô ʿ䰡 ̴. ׸ ̷ ǰ ʹ ϸ ݼӰ ݼ Ͽ ջ ִ.

, ռ Ѵ.  ÷ ʴ ٰ Ѵ. Ʒ Ѵ.

÷ ̳ Ȥ ٸ ڵ ȸ翡 ؼ ʴ´. ǻ, ̰ Ⱓ ȿȭ ų ִ.

, µ,  밡 ߾ ÷ ִ ٸ Ҹ ư ִ. ʰų Ȥ ƿ Ϸ 鿡Դ ̷ο ڵü  ؾ ϴ ƴ ɵ .

츮 ׷ٸ Tufoil Ϳ ϴ°? ̰ "PTFE ̸ڰ 굧 Ź̸, Ͽ Ѵ" ϸ鼭 Ǹŵǰ ִ. ׸ ̰ , ͸ ų Ȥ Ա ʴ´ٰ Ѵ. Ǵ Lubrilon ? ̰ ̷ ü Ǿ ݼ κ Ѵ. Ȥ Bishop's Original Permafused Lubrication Ѱ? ᱹ ̴. ְ ͸ ֱ ȯߴٸ ̷ ǰ ʴ . ׸ ͸ ϴ Ⱓ ִ ͵ . 츮 ο ǰ ƹ ٰ Ȯ . ׷ ڽ ڵ ϰ ϴ ̶ ̷ ǰ Ƹ ʿ ū ġ ϰ ִ ƴ ̴.


б ڷ

reader comments

Copyright 2000
Robert Todd Carroll

larrow.gif (1051 bytes) philosophical skepticism

Last updated 11/07/00

The   Sokal Hoax rarrow.gif (1048 bytes)